Implementing “Illinibucks” to
allow students at the University of Illinois to cut lines with regards to
registration and other services around campus, would make drastic changes to
the way these services are provided. Having been a part of the Division of
General Studies for two years at the University, I would allocate a majority,
if not all, of my Illinibucks towards registration. Being in the DGS, I was
always one of the last people to register and that led to having very eschewed
schedules and undesired professors/classes. Through this hypothetical system I
may have been able to move up the registration list. However, I feel that most
students would prioritize there bucks for registration because it has such a
large effect on your time spent in college. If there happened to be a tie in
use of bucks, would it then differ to your year in school? If this is the case
then we would essentially be back to the priority basis that we use for
registering now.
Due to a very high demand for
early registration, I could see the University setting the price for this
service relatively high to deter some students. For the deterred or less studious
students, these bucks could be used to cut lines at concerts, sporting events,
and maybe even registering campus facilities. The prices for these would be
less to raise the demand. If the University could not
lower the demand for early registration by raising its price, they could set a
maximum amount of bucks allowed to be spent for this service. This would be similar
to a government intervention in a real market. I would also wonder if the
University would allocate the same amount of bucks to each student or would
they allow students to purchase additional bucks. If this were the case, then
the University would be giving an advantage to students who could afford this
luxury. It would also affect the money supply and alter supply/demand.
Aside from that, would students have the bucks
tied to their university account, or would they be allowed to trade bucks to
other students? This would create another miniature economy where students
spend bucks not for campus services, but for services from other students. Clearly,
this could create legal issues for the University, but it would be interesting
to analyze this situation if it came to fruition. For students who really
wanted to register early, they could pay other students for their Illinibucks or do work for them. Due to the low supply of Illinibucks, they would raise in extrinsic value to the point that they could be seen as more valuable than real currency.
The implementation of Illinibucks would be a very interesting experiment. It would illustrate many economic models as well as show how the students prioritize the services that the University provides.
A different alternative is for you to buy a seat in a class from somebody who is already registered using Illinibucks for that purpose. This would be like somebody scalping tickets to a ballgame or a concert. The difference between the two from an economics perspective is that registration by time gets you access to all courses that are available at that time, while it may be you only care about one or two courses to get into for sure and the other courses you take you are willing to wait for what you can get. This bundling of courses in registration is probably necessary technology-wise, but it creates inefficiency from an economics perspective since people with high priority may get into classes that sell out that they don't value so much. It would be better for those students to drop those classes and let others in. With a price on a course by course basis, that can happen.
ReplyDeleteSorry for the late comment. I hadn't thought of setting specific prices for certain classes. This would give the University a very clear idea of the demand for specific classes. They could then begin to offer more sections or open it up to larger auditoriums. I'm sure they could implement some sort of auctioning system for class seats as well. This may take less advanced technology as you mentioned.
ReplyDelete